Pantry Items (Honey, Canned Goods, Sauces)

During the COVID-19 pandemic, our vendors are offering pre-order and pick up options for customers. Vendors are listed alphabetically, along with the items available for pre-order, how to order, and weekly pre-order deadlines.

To find vendors by product type, click on the links below:

Vegetables & Fruit | Mushrooms | Eggs | Meat | Cheese & Milk | Bread & Baked Goods | Prepared Foods & Drinks | Honey, Sauces & Condiments | Soap, Salve, and Lotions | Seedlings & Plant Starts

If you use EBT/Cumberland FRESH MATCH at market, you can still pre-order! Just let vendors know when you place your order. 

If you need a curbside/contactless pick up, please fill out this form or contact us

Black Rock Orchard (Fruit, Cider, Canned Goods) 

How to Order: 

Go to Black Rock's Pre-Order Site, select "Farmers on the Square" under Wednesday Pickup, and select your items. Pick up your order at the stand or fill out our form for curbside pickup.

Dickinson College Farm (Certified Organic Vegetables, Canned Goods, Beef Jerky, Pizza, Soap) 

How to Order: 

See pre-order options at the Dickinson College Farm's Blog. In addition to bringing pre-packaged orders for pickup at FOTS, the Dickinson College Farm will also have an array of fresh produce and pizzas for day-of purchasing. They accept credit card, cash or check. If you need a curbside pickup, fill out this form

Esh's Produce (Canned Goods, Eggs, Vegetables, Baked Goods) 

Canned Goods: $3.50 each or 3 for $10

16oz jars: 

  • Pickled Okra

  • Pickled Red Beets

  • Sweet Stuffed Peppers (Sweet, Mild, or Hot)

  • Salsa

  • Ketchup

  • Bread and Butter Pickles

  • Kosher Dill Pickles

  • Polish Dill Pickles 

  • Sour Dill Pickles

  • Sweet Dill Pickles

  • Lime Pickles

  • Banana Pickles

  • Hot Garlic Pickles

  • Horseradish Pickles


Jam (8oz jars):

  • Black Cherry

  • Black Raspberry

  • Blackberry

  • Elderberry

  • Peach

  • Grape

  • Strawberry

  • Strawberry-Rhubarb

  • Apple Butter


Eggs: $4/dozen

Spring Onions (limited amount)
Rhubarb (limited amount)

Maple Syrup:

  • 1/2 pint: $7

  • pint: $10

  • quart: $19


Chips (original and sour cream): $2/small, $6 large
Donuts: 3 for $3, $5.50/half dozen, $10/dozen

How to Order: 
Call (717) 532-3216 and leave your name, your order, and your phone number by 12pm Tuesday. If you need to pay by card, email and we will run your card over the phone. If you need a curbside pickup, fill out our form. 

Honey Bee Friendly (Honey, Salves, Lotions) 

How to Order: 

Order at Honey Bee Friendly's website by Tuesday night and select "In person pickup."

If you need a curbside pickup, fill out this form

Three Springs Fruit Farm (Fruit, Canned Goods, Vegetables) 

How to Order: 

Order at Three Springs Fruit Farm's website by Tuesday night. If you need a curbside pickup, fill out this form

Torchbearer Sauces (BBQ & Hot Sauce) 

$8 per bottle, 4/$25: 


  • Honey Mustard, 

  • OHMYGarlic, 

  • Carolina BBQ

  • Pineapple Papaya BBQ, 

  • Smokey Horseradish

  • Psycho Curry

  • Chipotle BBQ 

  • Coffee BBQ

  • Blueberry BBQ

  • Son Of Zombie

  • Tarnation Hot Sauce

  • Sultry Hot Sauce

  • Slaughter Hot Sauce

Superhots: $20 per bottle, 3/$40

  • Zombie Apocolypse

  • Rapture

  • Reaper Evil

  • Garlic Reaper

How to Order: 

Email John at by Tuesday night. If you need a curbside pickup, fill out this form

Whistleberry Farm (Mushrooms, Honey, Vegetables, Plant Starts) 

Fresh Mushrooms:

  • Fresh Oyster: $3/quarter lb, $6/half lb

  • Fresh Shiitake: $3/quarter lb, $6/half lb 

  • Fresh Lion's Mane: $3.50/quarter lb, $7/half lb


Raw honey:  $6.50 for 12 oz squeeze bear

Seedlings:  $3.00 each or 4 for $10.00 
See linked lists (herb seedlings list and vegetable seedlings list) for full descriptions. All plants are in 4 inch pots. 

How to Order: 

Email by Monday night. Orders must be paid for by Tuesday night. If you need a curbside pickup, fill out this form